Trump Comments on Alaska Senate Race, Refers to Proposed Agreement as a “Phony Deal”

Trump Questions Alaska Senate Election as Dan Sullivan Faces Tight Race Against Mary Peltola

President Donald Trump has intensified his criticism of Alaska’s closely contested U.S. Senate election, accusing Democrats of using additional candidates to weaken Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan’s chances of winning reelection. Trump also raised the possibility of criminal charges over what he described as an effort to mislead voters.

The comments come as election officials continue counting ballots in the race between Sullivan and former Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola. The contest remains unresolved, with Alaska’s ranked-choice voting system potentially playing a decisive role in determining the winner.

At the center of the controversy is the candidacy of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher whose name closely resembles that of the Republican incumbent. His appearance on the ballot triggered a legal dispute involving state election officials, Republican organizations and the courts.

Trump has characterized the situation as an attempt to manipulate the election. However, allegations that Democrats deliberately recruited candidates to confuse voters have not been established in court.

Trump Accuses Democrats of Using Spoiler Candidates

Trump criticized the Alaska Senate race on Monday, arguing that additional candidates had been placed on the ballot to reduce support for Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan.

“They put in a fake candidate, they put in two fake candidates, not one. And if you add them up, Dan Sullivan wins. But they put in two fake candidates!” Trump said in remarks shared on social media by conservative commentator Eric Daugherty.

The president’s comments focused on the presence of candidates whose participation, he argued, could affect the outcome of the closely divided contest.

The controversy has attracted national attention because Alaska uses a ranked-choice voting system. Under that system, voters can rank candidates in order of preference, and ballots can be transferred when lower-performing candidates are eliminated.

Trump’s criticism suggests that he believes votes cast for additional candidates could have changed the result in Sullivan’s favor. But the presence of multiple candidates on a ballot does not, by itself, establish that an organized effort to deceive voters took place.

The allegations remain disputed, and the final election outcome will be determined through Alaska’s established counting and tabulation procedures.

How Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. Reached the Ballot

The legal dispute centers on Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher from Petersburg, Alaska, who filed to run for the U.S. Senate seat held by Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan.

The two candidates have similar names, creating concerns among some Republicans and election officials that voters could mistakenly select the wrong candidate.

The Alaska Division of Elections initially rejected Daniel J. Sullivan Jr.’s candidacy in June. The agency determined that his filing did not demonstrate a good-faith intention to run for the office.

The challenger appealed that decision.

An Alaska Superior Court subsequently ruled that the state could not impose a good-faith candidacy requirement that was not established by the relevant constitutional qualifications. The court ordered election officials to include him on the ballot.

On June 29, the Alaska Supreme Court upheld the lower court’s decision, affirming that Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. could appear as a candidate. The court also directed the Division of Elections to determine how his name should be listed under existing ballot-design rules.

The legal decisions allowed both candidates named Sullivan to advance through the election process.

The court rulings addressed the candidate’s eligibility and the state’s authority to exclude him. They did not establish whether his candidacy was part of a coordinated political strategy.

Conservative Election Analyst Criticizes Court Decisions

Trump’s renewed criticism prompted conservative election analyst Seth Keshel to question the judicial decisions that allowed Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. to remain on the ballot.

“The Dems will argue they hit 50% anyway, but this is a deeper problem once again going back to the judiciary,” Keshel wrote on X.

He also argued that the Alaska Division of Elections had initially acted appropriately when it rejected the challenger’s candidacy.

“The Alaska Dept of Elections ruled the phony Sullivan off because it was a clear attempt to deceive voters. They were overruled by a court,” Keshel wrote.

Keshel further suggested that a similar controversy could emerge during the 2028 election cycle, when Republican Sen. Lisa Murkowski is expected to face voters.

“I can guarantee you if in 2028 Alaskans stick another Lisa Murkowski in the jungle primary the system will fall over itself to save the swamp Murkowski,” he wrote.

Keshel’s comments reflect his political assessment of the dispute. The courts’ decisions, however, were based on their interpretation of candidate eligibility requirements and constitutional protections.

Justice Department Lawsuit Was Dismissed Before Election Day

The Alaska Senate race also became the subject of a federal legal challenge before voters went to the polls.

In October, the U.S. Department of Justice filed a lawsuit seeking to prevent certification of the election results if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan lost.

The federal government argued that the presence of another candidate with a similar name raised concerns about voter confusion and whether the election process could produce a reliable result.

U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the lawsuit on November 1, two days before Election Day.

In her decision, Gleason said the Justice Department had not presented a workable plan for identifying and investigating ballots cast for Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. while protecting voter secrecy.

The judge also raised concerns about the federal government’s request to intervene in the state’s election procedures so close to Election Day.

The dismissal meant Alaska could proceed with its election and certification process under the existing rules.

The Justice Department’s lawsuit and the state-court proceedings were separate legal matters. Neither dismissal nor the earlier ballot ruling established that Democrats had organized a deliberate effort to manipulate the election.

Latest Alaska Senate Vote Totals Show Peltola in Front

Unofficial election returns released Saturday showed Democrat Mary Peltola leading the Senate race with 140,637 first-choice votes, representing 49.94% of the total.

Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan had received 129,424 votes, or 45.96%.

The two remaining candidates had received a combined total of more than 10,000 votes.

The figures showed Peltola with a lead of more than 11,000 votes over Sullivan in the reported count. However, she remained just below the 50% threshold required to win outright on first-choice votes.

The totals are unofficial and may change as election officials process and review additional ballots.

The outcome is particularly important because Alaska does not use a traditional one-round system for its general elections. If no candidate receives more than half of the active first-choice votes, the ranked-choice process determines the winner.

How Alaska’s Ranked-Choice Voting System Works

Alaska uses a ranked-choice voting system in which voters can list candidates in order of preference rather than selecting only one.

If no candidate receives more than 50% of the active first-choice votes, the candidate with the fewest votes is eliminated. Ballots cast for that candidate are then transferred to the next-ranked candidate still in the race.

The process continues until a candidate receives a majority of the remaining active ballots.

For the Alaska Senate contest, this means the votes initially cast for lower-performing candidates could influence the final result.

The preferences marked by voters on their ballots—not assumptions about how particular candidates’ supporters might vote—determine where those ballots transfer.

This distinction is important in the current dispute. Although Trump and some conservative commentators have argued that the additional candidates could have changed the outcome, the final effect depends on the actual rankings recorded by voters.

November 18 Tabulation Could Determine the Winner

Alaska election officials have scheduled the ranked-choice tabulation for November 18 if no candidate secures an outright majority after the final first-choice count.

The state is expected to certify the election results on November 25.

Until the tabulation is completed and the results are certified, the Senate race remains unresolved.

The controversy has placed Alaska’s election procedures, candidate eligibility rules and ranked-choice voting system under renewed national scrutiny.

Trump’s criticism has added a political dimension to the dispute, while the court decisions and ongoing vote count remain central to determining the final outcome.

For now, the key questions are whether Peltola can reach the required majority through the remaining count and how voters’ ranked preferences will affect the final round. The official result will depend on the ballots and Alaska’s election rules, not on the competing political claims surrounding the race.

Scroll to Top