DOJ Launches Investigation and Issues Hundreds of Subpoenas Over Alleged Election-Related Conduct

DOJ Issues More Than 200 Subpoenas in Alaska ‘Decoy Dan’ Election Investigation

The Justice Department has reportedly issued more than 200 subpoenas in its investigation into how a retired Alaska teacher with a name nearly identical to Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan ended up running against him in the 2026 U.S. Senate election.

The investigation centers on allegations that Democratic political operatives sought to recruit a second Dan Sullivan to appear on the ballot in an effort to confuse voters and potentially draw support away from the Republican incumbent.

The reported scale of the investigation became public on November 18, two days after Democrat Mary Peltola was declared the winner of Alaska’s Senate race.

According to Fox News Digital, two sources familiar with the investigation confirmed that more than 200 subpoenas had been issued. A law enforcement source also told the outlet that investigators were pursuing multiple targets across state lines.

The Justice Department has not publicly announced criminal charges arising from the investigation. The allegations remain under examination, and the people identified in reporting have not been convicted of any wrongdoing.

Two Candidates Named Sullivan Appeared on Alaska’s Senate Ballot

Alaska voters who cast ballots on November 3 encountered two candidates with nearly identical names in the U.S. Senate contest.

Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan was seeking reelection. The other candidate was Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher from Petersburg, a small community in southeastern Alaska.

Daniel J. Sullivan appeared on the ballot without a party affiliation. The remaining candidates were Democrat Mary Peltola, a former member of the U.S. House of Representatives, and Republican Gerald L. Heikes.

The similarity between the two candidates’ names became a major political controversy before Election Day.

Republicans argued that voters could mistakenly select the retired teacher while intending to vote for the incumbent senator. Allegations subsequently emerged that Democratic operatives had explored recruiting someone with the Sullivan name as part of a broader effort to influence the ballot’s composition.

Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee have denied wrongdoing. Peltola has also denied knowledge of the other Sullivan’s candidacy, according to reporting by the Associated Press.

Alaska Supreme Court Allowed the Retired Teacher to Remain on the Ballot

The dispute over Daniel J. Sullivan’s candidacy began months before the general election.

Alaska election officials initially moved to exclude him from the primary ballot after questions were raised about whether he was pursuing a genuine candidacy. The Alaska Republican Party also filed complaints challenging his eligibility.

The retired teacher appealed the decision.

In June, the Alaska Superior Court ruled that election officials had relied on a good-faith candidacy requirement that was not included in the relevant constitutional qualifications for the office.

The Alaska Supreme Court subsequently affirmed the decision, allowing Daniel J. Sullivan to remain a candidate and directing election officials to determine how his name should appear under existing ballot-design rules.

The court’s decision addressed his eligibility to appear on the ballot. It did not determine whether political operatives had recruited him to confuse voters or whether any criminal conduct had occurred.

Daniel J. Sullivan’s campaign reportedly raised $35,556, according to the figures cited in coverage of the controversy.

Federal Investigation Expands Beyond Alaska

The Justice Department’s investigation has examined whether people connected to Democratic political organizations coordinated efforts to recruit the second Sullivan.

The alleged effort has been described in reporting as the “ballot composition project.” The name refers to an alleged strategy of influencing which candidates appeared on the ballot, potentially affecting how voters distributed their support.

The investigation has reportedly extended beyond Alaska and involves individuals connected to Democratic campaigns and political organizations.

One prominent figure identified in the investigation is Marc Elias, a Democratic election attorney whose law firm represents Peltola’s campaign.

According to reporting by CBS News, Elias received a Justice Department target letter in connection with the investigation. Fox News Digital also reported that he was among those who received a criminal target letter.

A target letter is a formal notice that prosecutors consider someone a potential defendant in a criminal investigation. It generally indicates that investigators believe there is substantial evidence linking the recipient to possible criminal conduct.

However, receiving a target letter does not mean the recipient has been charged or that an indictment is certain.

Elias has strongly rejected the allegations and criticized the investigation as politically motivated. In a statement reported by CBS News, he said the administration was targeting him and his law firm because of their political and legal work.

The Justice Department has not publicly detailed the specific criminal statutes it believes may have been violated.

Democratic Campaign and Senate Committee Face Scrutiny

The investigation has also drawn attention to the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee, the national organization responsible for supporting Democratic Senate candidates.

Earlier reporting indicated that the committee received a grand jury subpoena as investigators examined the alleged recruitment effort.

The controversy intensified after reports suggested that individuals associated with Peltola’s campaign, the committee and outside Democratic political operatives may have participated in discussions about finding another candidate named Sullivan.

Those allegations have not been established in court.

Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee have denied wrongdoing. The central unresolved question is whether the second candidate’s entry into the race was an independent political decision or part of a coordinated effort to influence the election.

That distinction could be important to determining whether any conduct violated federal law.

Recruiting third-party or independent candidates to affect an opponent’s electoral prospects is a political tactic that has been used by both major parties. The existence of a candidate with a similar name, by itself, does not establish a criminal violation.

Trump Criticized the Alleged Recruitment Effort

President Donald Trump publicly criticized the controversy during the final stages of the campaign.

Trump called on Peltola to leave the race and questioned why Democrats would seek another candidate named Sullivan.

During an Election Day appearance on “Fox & Friends,” Trump said:

“But you had the Democrat Party look all over Alaska for somebody named Sullivan.”

His remarks reflected Republican accusations that the alleged recruitment effort was intended to undermine the incumbent senator’s reelection campaign.

The controversy also became part of the broader national dispute over election integrity and the use of political tactics to influence close races.

However, Trump’s statements were political commentary, not evidence establishing criminal responsibility. The Justice Department’s investigation must independently determine whether any individuals violated federal law.

Mary Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Race by 12,458 Votes

The investigation continued after Alaska’s Senate race was called for Mary Peltola on November 17.

According to the reported election totals, Peltola received 144,302 votes, defeating incumbent Dan S. Sullivan, who received 131,844.

The other candidates finished well behind the two leading contenders.

Republican Gerald Heikes received 6,105 votes, while Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. received 4,760.

Peltola’s margin over the incumbent was 12,458 votes. The combined total for Heikes and the second Sullivan was 10,865, meaning Peltola’s lead exceeded their combined vote totals by 1,593.

Peltola also surpassed the 50% threshold in the reported first-choice results, allowing her to win without requiring additional ranked-choice rounds.

Her victory gave Democrats another Senate seat and contributed to their expected 56-44 majority in the next Congress.

The result was particularly significant because Alaska had not elected a Democrat to the U.S. Senate since 2008.

Election Victory Does Not End the Criminal Investigation

Peltola’s victory did not bring the Justice Department’s investigation to a close.

A law enforcement source told Fox News Digital that the criminal case would continue regardless of the election outcome. The reported subpoenas and target letters indicate that investigators are continuing to examine communications and relationships among people potentially connected to the alleged recruitment effort.

The Justice Department has also pursued a separate civil case related to the election.

Federal officials sought to delay certification of the results over concerns about possible voter confusion. A federal judge dismissed that lawsuit, and the department has pursued an appeal.

The civil case and criminal investigation are separate proceedings. The dismissal of the civil lawsuit does not automatically end the criminal inquiry, just as the criminal investigation does not establish that the election result was unlawful.

The legal proceedings have raised broader questions about the limits of federal intervention in state election administration and the circumstances under which political recruitment efforts could violate federal law.

Questions Remain About Who Organized the Effort

The Alaska Senate controversy now involves several unresolved questions: who first proposed recruiting another candidate named Sullivan, who participated in the discussions, whether campaign or committee resources were involved, and whether anyone intended to mislead voters.

Investigators will also need to determine whether the available evidence supports any criminal charges under applicable federal statutes.

For now, the reported issuance of more than 200 subpoenas demonstrates the scope of the inquiry, but it does not establish that the alleged scheme occurred as described by Republican critics.

Peltola has been declared the winner, and the retired teacher’s appearance on the ballot was upheld by Alaska’s highest court. The criminal investigation, however, remains active.

The coming months could bring additional information about the alleged ballot-composition project, the involvement of political operatives and whether federal prosecutors ultimately decide to pursue charges.

Scroll to Top